Credit Suisse California Hotel CMBS Marks First Deal in 6 Years

Credit Suisse Group AG sold its first commercial-mortgage bond since 2008 with a $187 million deal tied to two beach-front hotels in Santa Monica, California.

Switzerland’s second-biggest bank is reentering the market as a surge in sales attracts new entrants, sparking concern lenders are loosening standards amid the competition. Credit Suisse’s last deal was an $887 million transaction in March 2008, according to data compiled by Bloomberg, three months before the market for securities tied to properties from skyscrapers to shopping malls shut down for more than a year in the wake of the financial crisis. 

Wall Street banks are poised to issue more than $100 billion of the debt in 2014 after sales doubled to $80 billion last year, Bloomberg data show. Loans contained in deals sold this year are “substantially weaker” than those backing transactions issued in 2013, Barclays Plc analysts said in a report this month. About $8.4 billion in CMBS has been offered since January.

Almost one-quarter of mortgages in 2013 offerings are based on incomes that are at least 10 percent higher than landlords reported during the previous 12 months, Barclays analysts led by Keerthi Raghavan said in the Feb. 7 report. So-called pro-forma underwriting allowed property owners to pile on more debt during the boom years leading up to the property market crash in 2008 on the assumption that future earnings would be higher.
New Department Zurich-based Credit Suisse, which tried to rebuild its origination team in 2011, fired 50 people in October of that year without completing a deal as Europe’s sovereign debt crisis roiled credit markets. The bank restarted the group again last year.

The lender, ranked by newsletter Commercial Mortgage Alert as the fifth most-active underwriter of CMBS globally when issuance peaked in 2007, is taking a cautious approach to new deals by avoiding the types of transactions that require lenders to hold as much as $1 billion of mortgages on their books for months, according to people with knowledge of its strategy.

This week’s transaction is backed by a mortgage linked to the Shutters on the Beach and the Casa Del Mar in Santa Monica, California, according to Morningstar Inc. Top-ranked securities maturing in seven years were sold to pay 85 basis points, or 0.85 percentage point, more than the one-month London interbank offered rate, according to a person familiar with the sale who asked not to be identified because terms aren’t public.

The Shutters on the Beach and the Casa Del Mar are the only two beachfront properties in Santa Monica, Morningstar said in a report earlier this month. In 2009, during the depths of the recession, revenue at the properties dropped about 19 percent, compared with a decline of 35 percent for comparable hotels, according to Morningstar.

Hotels are one of the most volatile commercial-property types as changes in the economic climate affect them almost immediately with rates resetting every night. In addition to the $183 million mortgage, the properties are carrying $186 million of mezzanine loans, according to Morningstar.

Market Volatility Drives Down CMBS Prices

Volatility in the stock and Treasury-bond markets put downward pressure on commercial MBS prices this week.

The 10-year Treasury yield finished at 2.16% yesterday, after falling to as low as 1.86% on Wednesday, as a plunge in the stock market touched off a flight to safety. The yield was down by 12 bp from last Friday and 46 bp from the recent high in mid-September.

The decline caused CMBS spreads to widen this week, for two reasons. First, credit spreads in general rose on concerns about the U.S. economic outlook, the European debt markets and spread of the Ebola virus. Also, investors were insisting on a higher spread to compensate for the decline in the Treasury yield.

Many CMBS buyers require a minimum absolute yield to take down new issues. In the last two conduit deals, the benchmark bonds yielded 3.29%. The long-term super-senior class of a $1.3 billion offering led by J.P. Morgan and Barclays (JPMBB 2014-C24) carried a spread of 83 bp over swaps. The comparable tranche of an $842 million issue led by Citigroup and Goldman Sachs (CGCMT 2014-GC25) priced at 87 bp over swaps.

Because of the drop in Treasury yields, the next conduit offering — a $1.2 billion transaction by Deutsche Bank, UBS, Cantor Commercial Real Estate and Natixis (COMM 2014-CCRE20) — will have to carry a wider spread to match that 3.29% yield. With the 10-year swap yield down to 2.328% yesterday, the benchmark spread would have to be 96 bp to reach 3.29%.

"That says it all right there," one CMBS banker said. "The spread will have to be 10-15 bp wider to get it done."

A pullback by some bond buyers is also putting pressure on spreads, according to one CMBS trader. "It’s a tough ride right now," he said. "Any time you have that kind of Treasury volatility, people put their pencils down and say, ‘Let’s think about what we’re doing.’ "

Virtually no bonds from recent conduit issues changed hands in the secondary market this week. But dealers have widened their bid-ask spreads, indicating that they were willing to buy long-term super-seniors from those deals at spreads of 94-96 bp and sell them for 90-91 bp.

Elsewhere in the new-issue market this week, Colony Mortgage Capital continued to market a $320.8 million securitization of seasoned performing mortgages collateralized mostly by multi-family properties. Bookrunners Credit Suisse and J.P. Morgan circulated price talk of 100-bp area over swaps on the only offered class — $220.6 million of bonds with a weighted average life of three years and a triple-A rating from Moody’s.

Meanwhile, RAIT Financial started shopping a $219.4 million offering backed by 22 floating-rate mortgages on various types of commercial properties. The $126.4 million senior class of 2.4-year bonds is rated triple-A by Moody’s and DBRS. The subordinate classes are rated only by DBRS, including a 2.8-year tranche of junior triple-As. UBS structured the transaction and is running the books with Citi.

UBS and Citi were also pitching a $335 million offering backed by the senior portion of a fixed-rate debt package on the 506,000-square-foot office tower at 1500 Broadway in New York’s Times Square. They originated the 10-year package last Friday, including $170 million of mezzanine debt, on a 50-50 basis for Tamares Real Estate of London. The transaction is rated by Moody’s, DBRS and Morningstar.

Ariz. Hotel Appraised Value Cut by 2/3

The 347-room Phoenix Airport Marriott, whose $63.8 million CMBS loan was transferred to special servicing last April, has been appraised at a value of $29.4 million. According to Barclays Capital, which highlighted the latest appraisal in a recent research note, the loan also became delinquent this month. The property originally was appraised at a value of $94.7 million.

The hotel, at 1101 North 44th St., near Phoenix’s Sky Harbor Airport and the campus of Arizona State University, was constructed in 1999. It is owned by Columbia Sussex of Crestview Hills, Ky., which until this month had kept the loan current, even though the property wasn’t generating sufficient cash flow.

Last year, for instance, the property generated $3.6 million of cash flow. That was 30 percent less than the amount required to fully service its loan, which was securitized through Banc of America

Commercial Mortgage Trust, 2006-3.

Barclays noted that the new, lower appraised value will lead to an appraisal reduction of about $35 million, which could increase interest shortfalls by $184,000. The deal’s A-J class, originally rated AAA by Standard & Poor’s and Fitch, would see an increase in shortfalls.

This month, the class was shorted $108,448 of interest. In addition, Barclays said that if the hotel was liquidated at near its appraised value, the deal’s class B, with a balance of $36.9 million and the most junior remaining in the deal, could be wiped out entirely and the A-J class could see a loss. The team added that the shortfalls, if they occur at that level, would be short-lived.